The Champs Voice
  • The Champs Voice
  • Movie Reviews
  • More from the web
  • Other Voices
  • Ask The Champ
  • About

Ireland’s Most Controversial Statues

27/6/2020

0 Comments

 
Picture
In a time long before digital channels, online archives, and mobile downloads we told our history through art, story, and public monuments. Ireland has a rich heritage of such artefacts, from Royal Mail post boxes painted green, to busts of poets, to megalithic tombs, and religious icons.  

Statues and monuments all across Ireland tell different stories from different time periods, which highlight the diversity and complexity of our journey through the ages.

Internationally there has been an energetic movement to challenge some of the more embarrassing elements of the past, with petitions to remove confederate statues from public parks in America closely correlated with a statue of slave owner Edward Colston taking a swim in Bristol.

The recent wave of mob justice over racist landmarks has stirred up a bit of fervour in Ireland too, with calls to remove some conspicuous, but perhaps misplaced sculptures, we face the possibility of erasing our history at the whim of a purist ideology which deems no statue should court controversy. In ancient times the practice of erasing someone from history was considered a fate worse than death, akin to being cast into oblivion. One of the most famous examples is that of the Egyptian Pharaoh Akhenaten who around 1353BC tried to convert his people to believe in one god, the sun god Aten. Some historians have made links between Akhenaten and the biblical character Moses, as he lead his followers out of Egypt and into the desert to start a new kingdom. On his death not only did his followers return to their old gods but the new pharaoh (Tutankhamun) had any record of his name or presence destroyed, to the extent that he wasn’t rediscovered until the late 19th century, and the history of ancient Egypt had to be completely rewritten.  
  
Erasing the past does not serve the same purpose as removing statues or symbols of hate that cause mass offence to a great number of people. As such it’s important that we are able to tolerate and respect the opinions of different groups in a shared society. This often means respecting monuments that we might not necessarily agree with. So here’s a little bit of info about the most controversial statues in Ireland and why we should keep them. 
Picture
1. IRA Leader Seán Russell

Following Ireland’s first true milestone in independence an unavoidable feud erupted which resulted in a violent civil war, the fallout of which resonated for many years. For some the hurt and bloodshed was never forgotten, which is why men like Seán Russell found themselves securing arms from the Soviet Union and Nazi Germany many years later.

The statue of Seán Russell in Fairview has been attacked several times, on the premise that he was a terrorist Nazi sympathiser who died on board a u-boat in 1940.

However the statue remains an important example of how Ireland’s history is far from a linear path; Seán Russell fought in the 1916 rising, the war of independence, and was so anti treaty that he favoured firearms over democracy till the day he died. His belief in continuing a forgotten war is a tragedy that repeated itself in Republican fanaticism for many decades more.

However it’s unfair to call him a Nazi or a Nazi sympathiser as in no way did he further the cause of Nazi Germany or align with their bigotry. In fact at the time Russell’s IRA were busy kicking fascist blue shirts and were closely linked to Fianna Fail until De Valera started to sever ties to maintain peace with the UK, under the guise that Ireland was to remain a neutral country during the European conflict.
​
The statue is a reminder that 1920 was not an easy struggle, that bloodshed is humanity lost, that bitterness lasts for many years. It remains in place as reminder that military action by Irish Republicans continued for longer than most people are comfortable with, and that finding peace was as big a task as winning independence. 
Picture
2. Christopher Columbus Monument

Yes this funny shaped block is number two on the list. In 2020 PBP Galway called for the removal of a sculpture gifted to Galway by the city of Genoa in 1992. The sculpture plays on loose historical records that Christopher Columbus visited Galway in 1477.

The ultra left wing group have taken offence to the genocidal colonisation of the New World by Columbus in 1492, his racial views of the indigenous people, and his contribution to the international slave trade of the time.

The danger of holding 15th century explorers to the ideals of 21st century morality is that we would end up tearing down everything we own. Christianity in the middle ages  is immersed in war, atrocity, and conquest. Of course PBP would just as likely remove all aspects of Christianity from public life, it’s as easy for them to remove an artistic monument about exploration as it is to remove statues of the virgin Mary from grottoes all over Ireland.

The argument that Galway Merchants were responsible for the slave trade is the same as blaming County Clare for the Iraq war, it’s meaningless to suggest a city/county without prosperous means is a participant in the acts of superpowers who bully their way through Ireland. Calling for its removal furthers the belief of conservatives that the far left are intolerant and a danger to their way of life. As such calling for its removal is premature given the debate on how we view conquistadors has only begun.

The monument itself has more to do with Ireland’s links with Europe, Galway’s historic ties with Italy and Spain, as well as the Irish desire for freedom & exploration. It was a gift to the city and it is a popular tourist attraction, serving more purpose near the Spanish Arch than in the quiet halls of a museum. 
Picture
3. Prince Albert Statue

Outside the Dail stands Prince Albert, husband to the Famine Queen and one of the last prominent statues of the British Empire in Ireland. A lot of people get upset at the thought of our former colonial masters trolloping around in the gardens outside the Oireachtas, and it’s certainly ironic considering we fought for a Republic to be independent of the rule of monarch and empire.

However the statue of Albert is a national treasure, sculpted by Irish artist John Henry Foley who also created the towering statue of Daniel O’Connell on O’Connell street. Again another example of how differences of opinion are very closely related in Irish history.  In fact there was another Foley statue of Queen Victoria in Dublin, but this was removed for safe keeping in 1949 and gifted to Australia in 1987, where people hold her in higher esteem.

Queen Victoria and Prince Albert visited Ireland at the height of the famine in 1849, history has not been kind to England’s handling of famine relief but at the time Victoria was welcomed with banners that read “Hail Victoria, Ireland's hope and England's glory”, and the people of Cork renamed Cobh as Queenstown after her visit. Its note worthy that despite the politics of the empire, and the conflict of war, there was no animosity for the royal visit at the time. So we should not be so quick to erase our history and the details of our relationship with Prince Albert.

Aside from the starvation of our people at the hands of the empire, it’s worth looking at Prince Albert and judging him by some of his actions. He was considered to have very liberal views, unlike other landowners of the time he opposed child labour and supported moves to raise the legal working age. He’s also known for his contribution to the Slavery Abolition Act of 1833, making slavery illegal throughout the empire.

Now try imagine what city life was like in the late 19th century, and that the progress of worker’s rights was often as a result of handouts from the ruling class of the time. Prince Albert seems to be a man of good conscious, as president of the Society for Improving the Conditions of the Labouring Classes he championed better housing conditions for the poor. This is no small feat either, especially given the narrative that landlords were very cruel to Irish tenants. 

So again it’s not clear that the statue of Prince Albert is grossly offensive, it’s a reminder of the past and the struggles for progress of human rights. It’s hard to say where statues are best placed but I also think there is little point in housing them all in a museum or gifting them to Queensland.
​
Personally I like touring around a city when I visit, and discovering different aspects of history at every location. It would be a shame to lose our rich and diverse range of monuments to appease a small group who show little tolerance to the stepping stones that lead us on the journey through our past, not all of which may be entirely glorious but none of which is profoundly grotesque. 
0 Comments

Nollaig na dTan

12/1/2020

0 Comments

 
Picture
What happened on the 6th of January 2020 could very well be the turning point in this year’s general election. Although a Fine Gael planned event to commemorate the forces of our 19th century oppressor was cancelled at the last minute, the general public remain at odds as to why Neo Leo would commemorate a force that presided over the famine, opposed the Tithe War, quelled the Young Irelander Rebellion, stood against the Fenian Rising, protected occupying gentry during the Land War, and were reinforced during the War of Independence by the brutal and savage Black & Tans.

As a result the average voter will closely associate Fine Gael with the Black & Tans and this will cost Fine Gael votes in the next election, there is no escaping that fact.
It’s also important to remember that Fine Gael’s RIC commemoration was cancelled as many of our elected officials refused the invite to attend;

Mayor Mike Cubbard (Galway City) tweeted that attending the event would be hypocritical as the RIC directly opposed those whose lives were lost creating the free Ireland we enjoy today.
​
Councillor Gary Gannon branded the RIC a terror squad and voted for Dublin City Council to boycott the ceremony. A DCC motion that passed successfully. The motion stated that “only a subservient government suffering from a post-colonial state of mind and ashamed of our revolutionary history would encourage this disgraceful event”.
​
Justice Minister Charlie Flanagan (dubbed on social media as Charlie Tanagan) took a seat in RTE 6.01 to deliver newspeak about how the commemoration was to give every consideration towards acknowledging all aspects of our history. Later we heard from opposition that the commemoration had not even been given cross party consideration - so it’s hard to understand how Charlie determined that he knew what was best for the whole country.

To add insult to injury Leo then proclaimed that the cancellation of the planned public riot was a step back for North-South relations, as if honouring the RIC was some kind of olive branch to people who continued to suffer human riots violations under the sister branch RUC until the reformation of the police service in Northern Ireland in 2001.

Fine Gael’s refusal to step away from the event has caused them long term damage, voters are hard to sway about complex issues such as housing and health and budget, but when it comes to evoking an emotional response that puts the Wolfe Tones to the top of the iTunes downloads charts in 2020 then it’s easy to predict FG will get a backlash at the polling stations.
0 Comments

Difficult Brexit

13/12/2018

0 Comments

 
Picture
 “England’s difficulty is Ireland’s opportunity” was James Connolly’s rally cry for the 1916 rising and following a bitter civil war our politicians took to the world stage looking to be recognised as a free nation.

It took years for our country to heal internally and also to reconcile our differences with an empire that ruled our small island nation by brutal force for hundreds of years.

It’s taken a long time to get here but Brexit has reminded us of how little our politics has matured. To suggest that Irish TD’s or MP’s should succumb to British rule in 2018 by supporting Theresa May’s Brexit deal is an insult to every Irish person who’s ever lived.
When the Irish Republic declared itself as a Sovereign Independent State it did so with the intent of abstaining from British politics, no longer would Ireland be a participant in its own enslavement.

For Fine Gael and Fianna Fail to ask Sinn Fein to take their seats in Westminster to support a deal that removes Northern Ireland from her rightful place amongst the nations of Europe is absolutely disgraceful. For Fine Gael and Fianna Fail to ask Sinn Fein to take their seats in Westminster to support a deal that the people of Northern Ireland voted overwhelmingly against is simply undemocratic. For Fine Gael and Fianna Fail to ask Sinn Fein to take their seats in Westminster to get England out of this difficulty is an absolute farce.  

What’s presented itself here is an opportunity for Irish people to decide whether they should vote for  parties that support British rule over Ireland

Or perhaps Irish people should decide they instead support parties that believe the right of the people of Ireland to the ownership of Ireland and to the unfettered control of Irish destinies.

Who would have thought that we would be faced with this choice a little over a hundred years after the Proclamation of The Irish Republic.  

The Queen’s agents need to be voted out of Irish politics. We will not go to England to vote ourselves backwards in time.

(Cartoon by @LatuffCartoons depicts Sinn Fein's Martin McGuinness meeting the Queen in 2012)
0 Comments
<<Previous

    The Champ's Voice

    www.facebook.com/thechampsvoice

    www.twitter.com/thechampsvoice


    www.instagram.com/thechampsvoice

    Categories

    All
    Abortion
    Advertising
    America
    Art
    Ask The Champ
    Border
    Cancer
    Children
    Christmas
    Church
    Comedy
    Dating
    Drinking
    Drugs
    Education
    Entertainment
    Equal Rights
    Europe
    Feminism
    Film
    Government
    Health
    History
    Housing
    Human Rights
    Ireland
    Letter
    Media
    Music
    Netflix
    Relationships
    Religion
    Social Media
    Society
    Sport
    Tax
    Twitter

    Archives

    August 2022
    May 2022
    November 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021
    March 2021
    November 2020
    October 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    May 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    November 2015
    October 2015
    July 2015
    May 2015
    March 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014

    RSS Feed

    RSS Feed

      Get even more TCV by e-mail

    Subscribe to Newsletter
    Follow @TheChampsVoice
Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.